MIDI note index in 'non' simplified output is '1' note off

Bugs
1

Got into something annoying when mapping midinotes to certain triggers.

I need to have ‘simplified output’ off, because I need different functionalities. But when I do that, compared to the ‘simplified output’ the notes are always 1 step off.

image
image1636×1022 84.4 KB

I’m just not sure if I’m missing something here. I feel like that the ‘simplified version’ can either be index 1 OR 0 based, but the non ‘simplified version’ is always 0 based, the ‘1 based index’ switch doesn’t seem to have an effect then.

2

Hi thanks for the report.
We’re having a look.

5

Hey Artechs,

Sorry that you’re having this issue.

I’m unable to reproduce it on my side though. Can you maybe share a toe file to demonstrate this more. And what build are you running?
In the attached screenshot, there are 2 Midi In CHOPs, and the parameters page is of midiin2 whereas the viewer you point to is of midiin1. Not sure if that was intended or I’m misunderstanding, so can you elaborate on that.

Thanks,
Varad

6

Hi Varad,

No worries, I can work around it.

Both midiinCHOPs are referring to the same device. The left CHOP has the switch ‘simplified output’ set to ‘on’, the right CHOP to ‘off’.

When I’m pressing a note on my device, the left CHOP gives me either ‘40’ or ‘41’ as a note, this depends on if I have switched on the ‘1 based Index’ on or off.

On the right CHOP, so that would be the one with ‘simplified output’ set to ‘off’, the switch ‘1 based index’ doesn’t work, its seems to be ‘0’ based always.

Best,

Stefan

7

Okay that makes sense and I am indeed able to reproduce the issue. Looks like the 1 Based Index toggle is working for Controls but not for Notes. We will have a further look, thanks.

Varad

8

Ah yes, that was the extra ‘annoyance’. I had to compensate the index for the notes, but the cc did map correctly. Thank you for looking into it!

9

Hey Artechs,

This will be fixed in the next experimental release.

Thanks,
Varad

10

Thank you!